The BalancedInvestor Club

Insurance Property Casualty Industry Analysis

46 companies analyzed • Returns from -95.9% to +63.6% • Data through May 1, 2026

Company List (46 Results)

View:
Sort:

Industry Performance

(46/46 companies)
2025-05-05 → 2026-05-01
Weighted Avg
-2.7%
Best
+63.6%
Worst
-95.9%
Returns Distribution
Top 5
1. LMND+63.6%2. MCY+49.8%3. UVE+43.5%4. HRTG+36.2%5. UFCS+35.4%
Bottom 5
1. ROOT-95.9%2. TRUP-62.5%3. KMPR-58.3%4. BOW-52.9%5. KNSL-38.1%

LMND

+63.6%

Lemonade Inc

MCY

+49.8%

Mercury General Corporation

UVE

+43.5%

Universal Insurance Holdings Inc

HRTG

+36.2%

Heritage Insurance Hldgs Inc

UFCS

+35.4%

United Fire Group Inc

L

+25.5%

Loews Corp

WTM

+22.3%

White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd

AIZ

+16.4%

Assurant Inc

DGICB

+15.5%

Donegal Group B Inc

HGTY

+15.0%

Hagerty Inc

HIPO

+14.1%

Hippo Holdings Inc

AII

+13.5%

American Integrity Insurance Group, Inc.

TRV

+13.0%

The Travelers Companies Inc

CB

+12.5%

Chubb Ltd

CINF

+11.9%

Cincinnati Financial Corporation

THG

+10.4%

The Hanover Insurance Group Inc

HMN

+8.5%

Horace Mann Educators Corporation

ALL

+7.9%

The Allstate Corporation

HIG

+7.7%

Hartford Financial Services Group

PRA

+7.1%

ProAssurance Corporation

1–20 of 46
Page 1 of 3
Methodology

The Weighted Average return (-2.7%) is calculated using market capitalization as weights. This gives larger companies more influence on the average, providing a more market-representative view.

45 companies with market cap data included: LMND, MCY, UVE, HRTG, UFCS, L, WTM, AIZ, DGICB, HGTY and 35 more...

Educational content · Not investment advice or recommendations

We're educators, not advisors. Your decisions are your own. Disclaimer