The BalancedInvestor Club

Insurance Property Casualty Industry Analysis

46 companies analyzed • Returns from -98.6% to +53.8%

Company List (46 Results)

View:
Sort:

Industry Performance

(46/46 companies)
2025-06-13 → 2026-06-11
Weighted Avg
-1.4%
Best
+53.8%
Worst
-98.6%
Returns Distribution
Top 5
1. UFCS+53.8%2. MCY+45.2%3. UVE+36.5%4. LMND+34.6%5. AIZ+26.5%
Bottom 5
1. ROOT-98.6%2. KMPR-93.5%3. TRUP-78.0%4. KNSL-42.3%5. PLMR-33.5%

UFCS

+53.8%

United Fire Group Inc

MCY

+45.2%

Mercury General Corporation

UVE

+36.5%

Universal Insurance Holdings Inc

LMND

+34.6%

Lemonade Inc

AIZ

+26.5%

Assurant Inc

NODK

+23.9%

NI Holdings Inc

L

+19.1%

Loews Corp

THG

+14.5%

The Hanover Insurance Group Inc

HGTY

+14.4%

Hagerty Inc

TRV

+14.3%

The Travelers Companies Inc

CINF

+14.0%

Cincinnati Financial Corporation

CB

+13.4%

Chubb Ltd

HMN

+13.1%

Horace Mann Educators Corporation

WTM

+10.9%

White Mountains Insurance Group Ltd

ALL

+9.9%

The Allstate Corporation

SIGI

+7.7%

Selective Insurance Group Inc

PRA

+7.4%

ProAssurance Corporation

AFG

+6.8%

American Financial Group Inc

KINS

+6.8%

Kingstone Companies Inc

DGICB

+5.0%

Donegal Group B Inc

1–20 of 46
Page 1 of 3
Methodology

The Weighted Average return (-1.4%) is calculated using market capitalization as weights. This gives larger companies more influence on the average, providing a more market-representative view.

45 companies with market cap data included: UFCS, MCY, UVE, LMND, AIZ, NODK, L, THG, HGTY, TRV and 35 more...

We're educators, not advisors. We don't make buy or sell recommendations under any circumstance. All content is for educational purposes. Past performance doesn't guarantee future results. Your decisions are your own. Disclaimer